Table D.2Applicability for included studies, KQ1

Author, yearPopulationInterventionComparatorOutcomeSetting
Abramov, 2019111Narrow eligibility criteriaN/AUnclearN/AN/A
Adams, 2009112Narrow eligibility criteriaN/AN/AN/AN/A
Ahmadi, 2021115UnclearN/AN/AN/ALevel of care different from that in the community
Algorta, 2016117N/AN/AN/AN/AN/A
Alloway, 2009119UnclearN/AN/AN/AN/A
Altınkaynak, 2020120Narrow eligibility criteriaN/AN/AN/ALevel of care different from that in the community
Amado-Caballero, 2020121UnclearN/AN/AUnclearUnclear
Arjona, 2023124UnclearN/AN/AN/AN/A
Bansal, 201228UnclearHighly selected intervention team or level of training/proficiency not widely availableN/AN/ALevel of care different from that in the community
Bard, 2013134N/AN/AN/AN/AN/A
Barkley, 1994135UnclearN/AUnclearN/AN/A
Berger, 2010141Narrow eligibility criteriaN/AN/AN/ALevel of care different from that in the community
Berger, 2017140Narrow eligibility criteriaN/AComparator unclearN/AN/A
Bergeron, 2017142UnclearN/AN/AN/AN/A
Beriha, 2018143UnclearN/AN/AN/AUnclear
Bledsoe, 2020152Narrow eligibility criteriaUnclearN/AN/AN/A
Bloch, 2012153More complex patients than typical of the communityN/AN/AN/ALevel of care different from that in the community
Boroujeni, 2019157UnclearN/AN/AN/ALevel of care different from that in the community
Boucugnani, 1989159UnclearN/AN/AN/AUnclear
Breaux, 2016162Narrow eligibility criteriaAs recommended or commonly used in practiceDiagnostic tools used differently than as recommended or commonly used in practiceOther issuesN/A
Bunte, 2013167More complex patients than typical of the communityN/AN/AN/ALevel of care different from that in the community
Burton, 2019168N/AN/AN/AN/ALevel of care different from that in the community
Bussing, 1998169More complex patients than typical of the communityUnclearN/AN/AN/A
Canivez, 2016170UnclearN/AN/AN/AN/A
Catherine Joy, 2021172UnclearN/AN/AN/AN/A
Caudal, 2011260N/AN/AN/AN/AN/A
Chan, 2022177N/AN/AN/AN/AN/A
Chang, 2019179Narrow eligibility criteriaN/AN/AN/AN/A
Chang, 2022182Narrow eligibility criteriaN/AN/AN/AN/A
Chang, 2023181More complex patients than typical of the communityN/AN/AN/ALevel of care different from that in the community
Charach, 2009183More complex patients than typical of the communityN/AN/AN/ALevel of care different from that in the community
Chelune, 1986184UnclearN/AN/AN/AN/A
Chen, 1994190Narrow eligibility criteriaN/AN/AN/ALevel of care different from that in the community
Chen, 2019187N/AN/AN/AN/ALevel of care different from that in the community
Chen, 2019188N/AHighly selected intervention team or level of training/proficiency not widely availableN/AUnclearN/A
Chen, 2020191UnclearN/AN/AN/ALevel of care different from that in the community
Chen, 2021189Narrow eligibility criteriaN/AN/AN/AUnclear
Chen, 2022185UnclearN/AN/AN/AN/A
Chen, 2023186UnclearN/AUnclearN/AN/A
Chiarenza, 2018192More complex patients than typical of the communityN/AN/AN/ALevel of care different from that in the community
Chow, 2019197Narrow eligibility criteriaN/AN/AN/AN/A
Chu, 2017198UnclearUnclearN/AN/ALevel of care different from that in the community
Cree, 2023210N/AN/AN/AN/AN/A
Crippa, 2017211UnclearHighly selected intervention team or level of training/proficiency not widely availableN/AN/ALevel of care different from that in the community
Culbertson, 1998213N/AN/AN/AN/ALevel of care different from that in the community
Das, 2021214UnclearN/AUnclearN/AN/A
Deb, 2008218More complex patients than typical of the communityN/AN/AN/ALevel of care different from that in the community
Deserno, 2022223UnclearN/AN/AN/AUnclear
Doyle, 1997230Narrow eligibility criteriaN/AN/AN/AN/A
Doyle, 2007231UnclearN/AN/AN/AN/A
Duda, 2016234More complex patients than typical of the communityUnclearN/AN/ALevel of care different from that in the community
Duda, 2017233More complex patients than typical of the communityN/ADiagnostic tools used differently than as recommended or commonly used in practiceN/AUnclear
DuPaul, 1992237More complex patients than typical of the communityN/AN/AN/ALevel of care different from that in the community
Ebesutani, 2010241More complex patients than typical of the communityN/AN/AN/ALevel of care different from that in the community
Edwards, 2015242More complex patients than typical of the communityN/AN/AN/ALevel of care different from that in the community
Eiraldi, 2000244More complex patients than typical of the communityN/AN/AN/ALevel of care different from that in the community
Ekhlasi, 2022245UnclearN/AN/AN/ALevel of care different from that in the community
Elkins, 2014251More complex patients than typical of the communityN/AN/AN/AN/A
El-Sayed, 1999246UnclearN/AN/AN/ALevel of care different from that in the community
Emser, 2018253N/AN/AN/AN/ALevel of care different from that in the community
Faraone, 2016263More complex patients than typical of the communityN/AN/AN/ALevel of care different from that in the community
Ferrin, 2012267N/AUnclearN/AN/ALevel of care different from that in the community
Forbes, 1998276More complex patients than typical of the communityN/AUnclearN/ALevel of care different from that in the community
Francois-Sevigny, 2022277More complex patients than typical of the communityN/AN/AN/ALevel of care different from that in the community
Gao, 2020282UnclearN/AN/AN/ALevel of care different from that in the community
Garcia-Argibay, 2022283N/AN/AN/AN/AN/A
Garcia-Sanchez, 1997284Narrow eligibility criteriaN/AN/AN/AN/A
Gardner, 2007285UnclearN/AN/AN/AN/A
Gargaro, 2014287More complex patients than typical of the communityN/AN/AN/AUnclear
Geurts, 2004293More complex patients than typical of the communityN/AN/AN/ALevel of care different from that in the community
Gibbons, 2020297More complex patients than typical of the communityN/AN/AN/AN/A
Gilbert, 2016298Narrow eligibility criteriaUnclearN/AN/ALevel of care different from that in the community
Goh, 2023299N/AN/AN/AN/AN/A
Gomez, 2018300N/AUnclearN/AN/AN/A
Gomez, 2021301N/AN/AN/AN/ALevel of care different from that in the community
Grazioli, 2023303More complex patients than typical of the communityN/AN/AN/ALevel of care different from that in the community
Grodzinsky, 1992307Narrow eligibility criteriaN/AN/AN/ALevel of care different from that in the community
Gungor, 2021309Narrow eligibility criteriaUnclearN/AN/AUnclear
Guttentag, 2022311Narrow eligibility criteriaN/AN/AN/AN/A
Hager, 2021312N/AN/AN/AN/ALevel of care different from that in the community
Hall, 2016315More complex patients than typical of the communityN/AN/AN/ALevel of care different from that in the community
Hall, 2020314More complex patients than typical of the communityN/AUnclearN/ALevel of care different from that in the community
Hamadache, 2021316More complex patients than typical of the communityN/AN/AN/ALevel of care different from that in the community
Hasaneen, 2017319Narrow eligibility criteriaN/AN/AN/ALevel of care different from that in the community
Helgadottir, 2015322N/AN/AN/AN/AN/A
Heller, 2013323More complex patients than typical of the communityUnclearN/AN/ALevel of care different from that in the community
Hinshaw, 2002327Narrow eligibility criteriaN/AN/AN/ALevel of care different from that in the community
Hong, 2019331More complex patients than typical of the communityN/AInadequate comparison therapy or use of a substandard alternative therapyN/AN/A
Hudziak, 2004336More complex patients than typical of the communityN/AN/AN/ALevel of care different from that in the community
Hult, 201824More complex patients than typical of the communityN/AN/AN/ALevel of care different from that in the community
Ickowicz, 2006338UnclearHighly selected intervention team or level of training/proficiency not widely availableN/AN/ALevel of care different from that in the community
Jacobson, 2020339N/AN/AN/AN/AN/A
Jahanshahloo, 2017340UnclearN/AN/AN/AUnclear
Jarrett, 2018342UnclearN/AN/AN/ALevel of care different from that in the community
Jensen-Doss, 2013344DSM-4/5 diagnosis unclearN/AUnclearUnclearN/A
Jimenez-Figueroa, 2017346N/AN/AN/AN/AN/A
Johansson, 2021347More complex patients than typical of the communityN/AN/AN/ALevel of care different from that in the community
Johnstone, 2021351Narrow eligibility criteriaN/AN/AN/ALevel of care different from that in the community
Juneja, 2019352Narrow eligibility criteriaN/AN/AN/AN/A
Kam, 2010355N/AN/AN/AUnclearN/A
Karabiber Cura, 2023356UnclearN/AUnclearN/AN/A
Karr, 2021359N/AN/AN/AN/AUnclear
Kennerley, 2018362N/AN/AN/AN/AN/A
Kim, 2015366Narrow eligibility criteriaUnclearN/AN/ALevel of care different from that in the community
Kim, 2015365Narrow eligibility criteriaN/AN/AN/ALevel of care different from that in the community
Koh, 2021369More complex patients than typical of the communityHighly selected intervention team or level of training/proficiency not widely availableN/AN/AN/A
Koh, 2022370More complex patients than typical of the communityN/AN/AN/ALevel of care different from that in the community
Krieger, 2021379Narrow eligibility criteriaN/AN/AN/ALevel of care different from that in the community
Kurokami, 2022382N/AN/AN/AN/ALevel of care different from that in the community
Lau, 2018385More complex patients than typical of the communityN/AN/AN/ALevel of care different from that in the community
Lee, 2022388UnclearN/AN/AN/AN/A
Lefler, 2012389UnclearN/AN/AN/AN/A
Lesica, 2023390Narrow eligibility criteriaN/AN/AN/AN/A
Levy, 2017391N/AN/AN/AN/ALevel of care different from that in the community
Li, 2005395N/AN/AN/AN/ALevel of care different from that in the community
Li, 2016393Narrow eligibility criteriaHighly selected intervention team or level of training/proficiency not widely availableN/AN/AN/A
Li, 2018394N/AN/AN/AN/AN/A
Liechti, 2013397N/AN/AN/AN/ALevel of care different from that in the community
Lin, 2022402N/AN/AN/AN/ALevel of care different from that in the community
Lin, 2023400N/AN/AN/AN/AN/A
Lin, 2023401Narrow eligibility criteriaN/AN/AN/AN/A
Lindhiem, 2022403UnclearN/AN/AN/AN/A
Liu, 2022404Narrow eligibility criteriaN/AN/AN/ALevel of care different from that in the community
Longridge, 2019405N/AN/AN/AN/AN/A
Luo, 2022408UnclearN/AN/AN/ALevel of care different from that in the community
Luo, 2022407UnclearN/AN/AN/AN/A
Marcano, 2018412Narrow eligibility criteriaHighly selected intervention team or level of training/proficiency not widely availableUnclearN/ALevel of care different from that in the community
Markovska-Simoska, 2017413Narrow eligibility criteriaN/AN/AN/ALevel of care different from that in the community
Martín-Brufau, 2017415UnclearN/AUnclearOther issuesN/A
Martin-Martinez, 2012416N/AN/AN/AN/AN/A
Matier-Sharma, 1995417More complex patients than typical of the communityN/AN/AN/ALevel of care different from that in the community
Maya-Piedrahita, 2022420N/AN/AN/AN/AN/A
Mayes, 2002421More complex patients than typical of the communityN/AN/AN/ALevel of care different from that in the community
Mayes, 2004422More complex patients than typical of the communityN/AN/AN/AN/A
Mayfield, 2018423N/AN/AN/AN/AN/A
McCarthy, 2016424More complex patients than typical of the communityN/AN/AN/ALevel of care different from that in the community
McIntosh, 1995427N/AN/AN/AN/AN/A
Merzon, 2022429N/AN/AUnclearN/AN/A
Mikolas, 2022434More complex patients than typical of the communityN/AN/AN/AN/A
Mitchell, 1990436UnclearN/AN/AN/AN/A
Miyahara, 2014437N/AN/AN/AN/AN/A
Moghaddari, 2020438N/AN/AN/AN/ALevel of care different from that in the community
Moura, 2017446More complex patients than typical of the communityN/AN/AN/AN/A
Moura, 2019445Narrow eligibility criteriaN/AN/AN/AN/A
Mouti, 2019447More complex patients than typical of the communityN/AN/AN/AN/A
Mulhern, 1994448More complex patients than typical of the communityN/AN/AN/AN/A
Muthuraman, 2019449Narrow eligibility criteriaN/AN/AN/AN/A
Mwamba, 2019450N/AN/AN/AN/AN/A
Newman, 2017462N/AN/AN/AN/AN/A
Nolan,1999463More complex patients than typical of the communityN/AN/AN/ALevel of care different from that in the community
Ogrim, 2012465N/AN/AN/AN/ALevel of care different from that in the community
O’Neill, 2021464More complex patients than typical of the communityN/AN/AN/AN/A
Oztekin, 2021467More complex patients than typical of the communityN/AN/AN/AN/A
Oztoprak, 2017468Narrow eligibility criteriaN/AN/AN/ALevel of care different from that in the community
Park, 2019469N/AN/AN/AN/ALevel of care different from that in the community
Parker, 201618N/AN/AN/AN/ALevel of care different from that in the community
Peijnenborgh, 2016470Narrow eligibility criteriaN/AN/AN/AN/A
Pereda, 2018473Narrow eligibility criteriaN/AN/AN/AN/A
Perugini, 2000475UnclearN/AN/AN/AN/A
Pineda, 2011477Narrow eligibility criteriaN/AN/AN/ALevel of care different from that in the community
Power, 1998479More complex patients than typical of the communityN/AN/AN/ALevel of care different from that in the community
Preston, 2005482More complex patients than typical of the communityN/AN/AN/AN/A
Qin , 2018486Narrow eligibility criteriaN/AN/AN/AN/A
Quintana, 2007487More complex patients than typical of the communityN/AN/AN/ALevel of care different from that in the community
Raiker, 2017491More complex patients than typical of the communityN/AN/AN/AN/A
Reddy, 2021493More complex patients than typical of the communityN/AN/AN/ALevel of care different from that in the community
Rezaeezadeh, 2020494UnclearN/AComparator unclearN/ALevel of care different from that in the community
Riaz, 2020495N/AN/AN/AN/ALevel of care different from that in the community
Rielly, 1999496More complex patients than typical of the communityN/AUnclearN/ALevel of care different from that in the community
Rishel, 2005498More complex patients than typical of the communityN/AN/AN/AN/A
Robles, 2021499More complex patients than typical of the communityN/AUnclearN/ALevel of care different from that in the community
Rodríguez, 2018500Narrow eligibility criteriaN/AN/AN/ALevel of care different from that in the community
Roessner, 2007501N/AN/AN/AN/AN/A
Rogers, 2022502More complex patients than typical of the communityN/AN/AN/ALevel of care different from that in the community
Rucklidge, 2002506N/AN/AN/AN/AN/A
Satin, 1985514Narrow eligibility criteriaN/AN/AN/AN/A
Schatz, 2001515Narrow eligibility criteriaN/AN/AN/AN/A
Scheeringa, 2020516More complex patients than typical of the communityN/AN/AN/ALevel of care different from that in the community
Schirmer, 2021518UnclearN/AN/AN/ALevel of care different from that in the community
Schneider, 2020519N/AN/AN/AN/AN/A
Serrallach, 2016524More complex patients than typical of the communityUnclearUnclearN/AN/A
Shemmassian, 2016527N/AN/AN/AN/AN/A
Shemmassian, 2017528N/AN/AN/AN/AN/A
Silverstein, 2016536N/AN/AN/AN/AN/A
Simões, 2021537Narrow eligibility criteriaN/AN/AN/AN/A
Skogli, 2013541N/AN/AN/AN/ALevel of care different from that in the community
Slaby, 2022542UnclearN/AUnclearN/AN/A
Slobodin, 2020543UnclearN/AN/AN/ALevel of care different from that in the community
Smith, 2000547UnclearN/AN/AN/ALevel of care different from that in the community
Smith, 2003546Narrow eligibility criteriaN/AN/AN/AN/A
Snyder, 2008548More complex patients than typical of the communityN/AN/AN/ALevel of care different from that in the community
Snyder, 201527N/AN/ADiagnostic tools used differently than as recommended or commonly used in practiceN/AN/A
Soliva, 2010549UnclearN/AN/AN/ALevel of care different from that in the community
Spencer, 2018553More complex patients than typical of the communityN/AN/AN/AN/A
Sprafkin, 2002559More complex patients than typical of the communityN/AN/AN/ALevel of care different from that in the community
Sprafkin, 2007558More complex patients than typical of the communityN/AN/AN/ALevel of care different from that in the community
Stepanova, 2021563N/AN/AN/AN/AN/A
Stevanovic, 2023564More complex patients than typical of the communityN/AUnclearN/AN/A
Straub, 2021566More complex patients than typical of the communityHighly selected intervention team or level of training/proficiency not widely availableN/AN/ALevel of care different from that in the community
Sullivan, 2007570N/AN/AN/AN/AN/A
Sun, 2018571Narrow eligibility criteriaN/AN/AN/ALevel of care different from that in the community
Tallberg, 2019576N/AHighly selected intervention team or level of training/proficiency not widely availableN/AN/AN/A
Tang, 2022581N/AN/AN/AN/ALevel of care different from that in the community
Tang, 2023580UnclearN/AN/AN/ALevel of care different from that in the community
Ter-Minassian, 2022582N/AN/AN/AN/AN/A
Tian, 2022583Narrow eligibility criteriaN/AN/AN/AN/A
Tillman, 2005584UnclearN/AN/AN/AN/A
Tripp, 2006587More complex patients than typical of the communityN/AN/AN/AUnclear
Uyulan, 2023591UnclearN/AN/AN/AN/A
Vahid, 2019592N/AN/AN/AUnclearN/A
Varela Casal, 2019599N/AHighly selected intervention team or level of training/proficiency not widely availableN/AN/ALevel of care different from that in the community
Vogt, 2011600More complex patients than typical of the communityN/AN/AN/ALevel of care different from that in the community
Wang, 2018603Narrow eligibility criteriaHighly selected intervention team or level of training/proficiency not widely availableN/AN/ALevel of care different from that in the community
Wassenberg, 2004605More complex patients than typical of the communityN/AN/AN/ALevel of care different from that in the community
Webster, 2000607DSM-4/5 diagnosis unclearN/AN/AN/AN/A
Westerberg, 2004614Narrow eligibility criteriaN/AN/AN/AN/A
Weyandt, 1994615UnclearN/AN/AN/AN/A
Williams, 201021N/AUnclearN/AN/AN/A
Wodka, 2008625N/AN/AN/AN/AN/A
Wood, 2009627N/AN/AN/AN/AN/A
Yao, 2018630Narrow eligibility criteriaN/AN/AN/ALevel of care different from that in the community
Yasumura, 2020631Narrow eligibility criteriaN/AN/AN/AN/A
Yeh, 2020632Narrow eligibility criteriaN/AN/AN/ALevel of care different from that in the community
Yoo, 2020633Narrow eligibility criteriaN/AN/AN/ALevel of care different from that in the community
Zadehbagheri, 2019635N/AN/AN/AN/AN/A
Zelko, 1991638N/AN/AN/AN/AN/A
Zelnik, 2012639N/AN/AN/AN/ALevel of care different from that in the community
Zhou, 2018642N/AN/AComparator unclearN/AN/A
Zhou, 2022641UnclearHighly selected intervention team or level of training/proficiency not widely availableN/AN/AN/A
Zhu, 2022644N/AN/AN/AN/ALevel of care different from that in the community
Zulueta, 2019647N/AN/AN/AN/AN/A

From: Appendix D, Critical Appraisal and Applicability Tables

Cover of ADHD Diagnosis and Treatment in Children and Adolescents
ADHD Diagnosis and Treatment in Children and Adolescents [Internet].
Comparative Effectiveness Review, No. 267.
Peterson BS, Trampush J, Maglione M, et al.

NCBI Bookshelf. A service of the National Library of Medicine, National Institutes of Health.