This work was produced by Maben et al. under the terms of a commissioning contract issued by the Secretary of State for Health and Social Care. This is an Open Access publication distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution CC BY 4.0 licence, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, reproduction and adaptation in any medium and for any purpose provided that it is properly attributed. See: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/. For attribution the title, original author(s), the publication source – NIHR Journals Library, and the DOI of the publication must be cited.
NCBI Bookshelf. A service of the National Library of Medicine, National Institutes of Health.
Maben J, Taylor C, Jagosh J, et al. Causes and solutions to workplace psychological ill-health for nurses, midwives and paramedics: the Care Under Pressure 2 realist review. Southampton (UK): National Institute for Health and Care Research; 2024 Apr. (Health and Social Care Delivery Research, No. 12.09.)
Causes and solutions to workplace psychological ill-health for nurses, midwives and paramedics: the Care Under Pressure 2 realist review.
Show detailsInitial Database Search
Database: MEDLINE
Host: Ovid
Issue: 1946 to February 10, 2021
Date searched: 12/2/2021
Searcher: SB
Hits: 405 (nurses); 40 (midwives); 6 (paramedics)
Strategy:
- (nurse or nurses or nursing).tw.
- nursing/
- exp specialties, nursing/
- or/1-3
- (midwif* or midwives).tw.
- Midwifery/
- 5 or 6
- paramedic*.tw.
- Emergency Medical Technicians/
- 8 or 9
- (‘mental health’ or ‘mental ill health’ or stress* or distress* or anxiety or anxious or depression or depressed or ‘wellbeing’ or wellbeing or resilienc*).tw.
- (pressure* adj3 (work* or ‘patient* demand*’)).tw.
- *Mental Health/
- Stress, Psychological/
- *Depression/
- *Anxiety/
- or/11-16
- (retention or presenteeism or absenteeism or ‘sick leave’ or burnout or ‘burn* out’).tw.
- Presenteeism/
- *Absenteeism/
- *Sick Leave/
- or/18–21
- exp United Kingdom/
- (national health service* or nhs*).ti,ab,in.
- (english not ((published or publication* or translat* or written or language* or speak* or literature or citation*) adj5 english)).ti,ab.
- (gb or ‘g.b.’ or britain* or (british* not ‘british columbia’) or uk or ‘u.k.’ or united kingdom* or (england* not ‘new england’) or northern ireland* or northern irish* or scotland* or scottish* or ((wales or ‘south wales’) not ‘new south wales’) or welsh*).ti,ab,jw,in.
- (bath or ‘bath’s’ or ((birmingham not alabama*) or (‘birmingham’s’ not alabama*) or bradford or ‘bradford’s’ or brighton or ‘brighton’s’ or bristol or ‘bristol’s’ or carlisle* or ‘carlisle’s’ or (cambridge not (massachusetts* or boston* or harvard*)) or (‘cambridge’s’ not (massachusetts* or boston* or harvard*)) or (canterbury not zealand*) or (‘canterbury’s’ not zealand*) or chelmsford or ‘chelmsford’s’ or chester or ‘chester’s’ or chichester or ‘chichester’s’ or coventry or ‘coventry’s’ or derby or ‘derby’s’ or (durham not (carolina* or nc)) or (‘durham’s’ not (carolina* or nc)) or ely or ‘ely’s’ or exeter or ‘exeter’s’ or gloucester or ‘gloucester’s’ or hereford or ‘hereford’s’ or hull or ‘hull’s’ or lancaster or ‘lancaster’s’ or leeds* or leicester or ‘leicester’s’ or (lincoln not nebraska*) or (‘lincoln’s’ not nebraska*) or (liverpool not (new south wales* or nsw)) or (‘liverpool’s’ not (new south wales* or nsw)) or ((london not (ontario* or ont or toronto*)) or (‘london’s’ not (ontario* or ont or toronto*)) or manchester or ‘manchester’s’ or (newcastle not (new south wales* or nsw)) or (‘newcastle’s’ not (new south wales* or nsw)) or norwich or ‘norwich’s’ or nottingham or ‘nottingham’s’ or oxford or ‘oxford’s’ or peterborough or ‘peterborough’s’ or plymouth or ‘plymouth’s’ or portsmouth or ‘portsmouth’s’ or preston or ‘preston’s’ or ripon or ‘ripon’s’ or salford or ‘salford’s’ or salisbury or ‘salisbury’s’ or sheffield or ‘sheffield’s’ or southampton or ‘southampton’s’ or st albans or stoke or ‘stoke’s’ or sunderland or ‘sunderland’s’ or truro or ‘truro’s’ or wakefield or ‘wakefield’s’ or wells or westminster or ‘westminster’s’ or winchester or ‘winchester’s’ or wolverhampton or ‘wolverhampton’s’ or (worcester not (massachusetts* or boston* or harvard*)) or (‘worcester’s’ not (massachusetts* or boston* or harvard*)) or (york not (‘new york*’ or ny or ontario* or ont or toronto*)) or (‘york’s’ not (‘new york*’ or ny or ontario* or ont or toronto*))))).ti,ab,in.
- (bangor or ‘bangor’s’ or cardiff or ‘cardiff’s’ or newport or ‘newport’s’ or st asaph or ‘st asaph’s’ or st davids or swansea or ‘swansea’s’).ti,ab,in.
- (aberdeen or ‘aberdeen’s’ or dundee or ‘dundee’s’ or edinburgh or ‘edinburgh’s’ or glasgow or ‘glasgow’s’ or inverness or (perth not australia*) or (‘perth’s’ not australia*) or stirling or ‘stirling’s’).ti,ab,in.
- (armagh or ‘armagh’s’ or belfast or ‘belfast’s’ or lisburn or ‘lisburn’s’ or londonderry or ‘londonderry’s’ or derry or ‘derry’s’ or newry or ‘newry’s’).ti,ab,in.
- or/23-30
- (exp africa/or exp americas/or exp antarctic regions/or exp arctic regions/or exp asia/or exp australia/or exp oceania/) not (exp United Kingdom/or europe/)
- 31 not 32
- 4 and 17 and 22 and 33[Nursing literature]
- 7 and 17 and 22 and 33[Midwifery literature]
- 10 and 17 and 22 and 33[Paramedics literature]
Database: CINAHL
Host: EBSCO
Issue: n/a
Date searched: 12/2/2021
Searcher: SB
Hits: 844 (nurses); 60 (midwives); 16 (paramedics)
Strategy: Available on request from the authors.
Notes: EBSCO UK/Ireland geographic limit applied.
Database: HMIC
Host: Ovid
Issue: 1974 to January 2021
Date searched: 26/2/2021
Searcher: SB
Hits: 243 (nurses); 9 (midwives); 3 (paramedics)
Strategy: Available on request from the authors.
Revised paramedic search
Database: MEDLINE
Host: Ovid
Issue: 1946 to March 30, 2021
Date searched: 31 March 2021
Searcher: SB
Hits: 24
Strategy:
- paramedic*.tw.
- (emergency adj2 (attendant* or personnel or responder* or technician*)).tw.
- (ems or emt).tw.
- (prehospital or ‘pre hospital’).tw.
- ‘first responder*’.tw.
- ‘emergency services’.tw.
- ambulance*.tw.
- HEMS.tw.
- ‘field triage*’.tw.
- ‘out of hospital’.tw.
- (‘trauma risk management’ or TRIM).tw.
- Emergency Medical Technicians/
- Emergency Medical Services/
- Emergency Responders/
- Ambulances/
- Air Ambulances/
- or/1-16
- (‘mental health’ or ‘mental ill health’ or stress* or distress* or anxiety or anxious or depression or depressed or ‘wellbeing’ or wellbeing or resilienc*).tw.
- (pressure* adj3 (work* or ‘patient* demand*’)).tw.
- *Mental Health/
- Stress, Psychological/
- *Depression/
- *Anxiety/
- or/18-23
- (retention or presenteeism or absenteeism or a ‘sick leave’ or burnout or ‘burn* out’).tw.
- Presenteeism/
- *Absenteeism/
- *Sick Leave/
- or/25-28
- exp United Kingdom/
- (national health service* or nhs*).ti,ab,in.
- (english not ((published or publication* or translat* or written or language* or speak* or literature or citation*) adj5 english)).ti,ab.
- (gb or ‘g.b.’ or britain* or (british* not ‘british columbia’) or uk or ‘u.k.’ or united kingdom* or (england* not ‘new england’) or northern ireland* or northern irish* or scotland* or scottish* or ((wales or ‘south wales’) not ‘new south wales’) or welsh*).ti,ab,jw,in.
- (bath or ‘bath’s’ or ((birmingham not alabama*) or (‘birmingham’s’ not alabama*) or bradford or ‘bradford’s’ or brighton or ‘brighton’s’ or bristol or ‘bristol’s’ or carlisle* or ‘carlisle’s’ or (cambridge not (massachusetts* or boston* or harvard*)) or (‘cambridge’s’ not (massachusetts* or boston* or harvard*)) or (canterbury not zealand*) or (‘canterbury’s’ not zealand*) or chelmsford or ‘chelmsford’s’ or chester or ‘chester’s’ or chichester or ‘chichester’s’ or coventry or ‘coventry’s’ or derby or ‘derby’s’ or (durham not (carolina* or nc)) or (‘durham’s’ not (carolina* or nc)) or ely or ‘ely’s’ or exeter or ‘exeter’s’ or gloucester or ‘gloucester’s’ or hereford or ‘hereford’s’ or hull or ‘hull’s’ or lancaster or ‘lancaster’s’ or leeds* or leicester or ‘leicester’s’ or (lincoln not nebraska*) or (‘lincoln’s’ not nebraska*) or (liverpool not (new south wales* or nsw)) or (‘liverpool’s’ not (new south wales* or nsw)) or ((london not (ontario* or ont or toronto*)) or (‘london’s’ not (ontario* or ont or toronto*)) or manchester or ‘manchester’s’ or (newcastle not (new south wales* or nsw)) or (‘newcastle’s’ not (new south wales* or nsw)) or norwich or ‘norwich’s’ or nottingham or ‘nottingham’s’ or oxford or ‘oxford’s’ or peterborough or ‘peterborough’s’ or plymouth or ‘plymouth’s’ or portsmouth or ‘portsmouth’s’ or preston or ‘preston’s’ or ripon or ‘ripon’s’ or salford or ‘salford’s’ or salisbury or ‘salisbury’s’ or sheffield or ‘sheffield’s’ or southampton or ‘southampton’s’ or st albans or stoke or ‘stoke’s’ or sunderland or ‘sunderland’s’ or truro or ‘truro’s’ or wakefield or ‘wakefield’s’ or wells or westminster or ‘westminster’s’ or winchester or ‘winchester’s’ or wolverhampton or ‘wolverhampton’s’ or (worcester not (massachusetts* or boston* or harvard*)) or (‘worcester’s’ not (massachusetts* or boston* or harvard*)) or (york not (‘new york*’ or ny or ontario* or ont or toronto*)) or (‘york’s’ not (‘new york*’ or ny or ontario* or ont or toronto*))))).ti,ab,in.
- (bangor or ‘bangor’s’ or cardiff or ‘cardiff’s’ or newport or ‘newport’s’ or st asaph or ‘st asaph’s’ or st davids or swansea or ‘swansea’s’).ti,ab,in.
- (aberdeen or ‘aberdeen’s’ or dundee or ‘dundee’s’ or edinburgh or ‘edinburgh’s’ or glasgow or ‘glasgow’s’ or inverness or (perth not australia*) or (‘perth’s’ not australia*) or stirling or ‘stirling’s’).ti,ab,in.
- (armagh or ‘armagh’s’ or belfast or ‘belfast’s’ or lisburn or ‘lisburn’s’ or londonderry or ‘londonderry’s’ or derry or ‘derry’s’ or newry or ‘newry’s’).ti,ab,in.
- or/30-37
- (exp africa/or exp americas/or exp antarctic regions/or exp arctic regions/or exp Asia/or exp australia/or exp oceania/) not (exp United Kingdom/or Europe/)
- 38 not 39
- 17 and 24 and 29 and 40
Database: CINAHL
Host: EBSCO
Issue: n/a
Date searched: 31 March 2021
Searcher: SB
Hits: 56
Strategy: Available on request from the authors.
Notes: EBSCO UK/Ireland geographic limit applied.
Database: HMIC
Host: Ovid
Issue: 1979 to January 2021
Date searched: 31 March 2021
Searcher: SB
Hits: 7
Strategy: Available on request from the authors.
COVID search
Database: CINAHL
Host: EBSCO
Issue: n/a
Date searched: 7/12/2021
Searcher: SB
Hits: Nurses: 1355; midwives: 75; paramedics: 227
Strategy:
- TI (nurse or nurses or nursing) OR AB (nurse or nurses or nursing)
- (MH ‘Nurses+’)
- S1 OR S2
- TI (midwif* or midwives) OR AB (midwif* or midwives)
- (MH ‘Midwifery+’)
- S4 OR S5
- TI paramedic* OR AB paramedic*
- TI ((emergency N1 (attendant* or personnel or responder* or technician*))) OR AB ((emergency N1 (attendant* or personnel or responder* or technician*)))
- TI (ems or emt) OR AB (ems or emt)
- TI (prehospital or ‘pre hospital’) OR AB (prehospital or ‘pre hospital’)
- TI ‘first responder*’ OR AB ‘first responder*’
- TI ‘emergency services’ OR AB ‘emergency services’
- TI ambulance* OR AB ambulance*
- TI HEMS OR AB HEMS
- TI ‘field triage*’ OR AB ‘field triage*’
- TI ‘out of hospital’ OR AB ‘out of hospital’
- TI ((‘trauma risk management’ or TRIM)) OR AB ((‘trauma risk management’ or TRIM))
- (MH ‘Emergency Medical Technicians’)
- (MH ‘Emergency Medical Services+’)
- (MH ‘Ambulances’)
- S7 OR S8 OR S9 OR S10 OR S11 OR S12 OR S13 OR S14 OR S15 OR S16 OR S17 OR S18 OR S19 OR S20
- TI (‘mental health’ or ‘mental ill health’ or stress* or distress* or anxiety or anxious or depression or depressed or ‘wellbeing’ or wellbeing or resilienc*) OR AB (‘mental health’ or ‘mental ill health’ or stress* or distress* or anxiety or anxious or depression or depressed or ‘wellbeing’ or wellbeing or resilienc*)
- TI (pressure* N2 (work* or ‘patient* demand*’)) OR AB (pressure* N2 (work* or ‘patient* demand*’))
- (MM ‘Mental Health’)
- (MH ‘Stress, Psychological’)
- (MM ‘Depression’)
- (MM ‘Anxiety’)
- S22 OR S23 OR S24 OR S25 OR S26 OR S27
- TI ((coronavirus* or coronovirus* or coronoravirus* or coronaravirus* or ‘corono virus*’ or ‘corona virus*’)) OR AB ((coronavirus* or coronovirus* or coronoravirus* or coronaravirus* or ‘corono virus*’ or ‘corona virus*’))
- (MH ‘Coronavirus’)
- (MH ‘Coronavirus Infections’)
- TI ((‘COVID-19’ or ‘CORVID-19’ or ‘2019nCoV’ or ‘2019-nCoV’ or ‘WN-CoV’ or nCoV or ‘SARS-CoV-2’ or ‘HCoV-19’ or ‘novel coronavirus’)) OR AB ((‘COVID-19’ or ‘CORVID-19’ or ‘2019nCoV’ or ‘2019-nCoV’ or ‘WN-CoV’ or nCoV or ‘SARS-CoV-2’ or ‘HCoV-19’ or ‘novel coronavirus’))
- (MH ‘COVID-19’)
- (MH ‘SARS-CoV-2’)
- (MH ‘COVID-19 Testing’)
- (MH ‘COVID-19 Vaccines’)
- S29 OR S30 OR S31 OR S32 OR S33 OR S34 OR S35 OR S36
- S3 AND S28 AND S37 (Nurses)
- S6 AND S28 AND S37 (Midwives)
- S21 AND S28 AND S37 (Paramedics)
Database: MEDLINE ALL
Host: Ovid
Issue: 1946 to December 06, 2021
Date searched: 7/12/2021
Searcher: SB
Hits: nurses: 210; midwives: 15; paramedics: 55
Strategy:
- (nurse or nurses or nursing).tw.
- nursing/
- exp specialties, nursing/
- or/1-3
- (midwif* or midwives).tw.
- Midwifery/
- 5 or 6
- paramedic*.tw.
- (emergency adj2 (attendant* or personnel or responder* or technician*)).tw.
- (ems or emt).tw.
- (prehospital or ‘pre hospital’).tw.
- ‘first responder*’.tw.
- ‘emergency services’.tw.
- ambulance*.tw.
- HEMS.tw.
- ‘field triage*’.tw.
- ‘out of hospital’.tw.
- (‘trauma risk management’ or TRIM).tw.
- Emergency Medical Technicians/
- Emergency Medical Services/
- Emergency Responders/
- Ambulances/
- Air Ambulances/
- or/8-23
- (‘mental health’ or ‘mental ill health’ or stress* or distress* or anxiety or anxious or depression or depressed or ‘wellbeing’ or wellbeing or resilienc*).tw.
- (pressure* adj3 (work* or ‘patient* demand*’)).tw.
- ‘emergency services’.tw.
- *Mental Health/
- Stress, Psychological/
- *Depression/
- *Anxiety/
- or/25-30
- (coronavirus* or coronovirus* or coronoravirus* or coronaravirus* or ‘corono virus*’ or ‘corona virus*’).tw.
- Coronavirus/
- Coronavirus Infections/
- (‘COVID-19’ or ‘CORVID-19’ or ‘2019nCoV’ or ‘2019-nCoV’ or ‘WN-CoV’ or nCoV or ‘SARS-CoV-2’ or ‘HCoV-19’ or ‘novel coronavirus’).tw.
- COVID-19/
- SARS-CoV-2/
- COVID-19 Serological Testing/
- COVID-19 Nucleic Acid Testing/
- COVID-19 Testing/
- COVID-19 Vaccines/
- or/33-42
- exp United Kingdom/
- (national health service* or nhs*).ti,ab,in.
- (english not ((published or publication* or translat* or written or language* or speak* or literature or citation*) adj5 english)).ti,ab.
- (gb or ‘g.b.’ or britain* or (british* not ‘british columbia’) or uk or ‘u.k.’ or united kingdom* or (england* not ‘new england’) or northern ireland* or northern irish* or scotland* or scottish* or ((wales or ‘south wales’) not ‘new south wales’) or welsh*).ti,ab,jw,in.
- (bath or ‘bath’s’ or ((birmingham not alabama*) or (‘birmingham’s’ not alabama*) or bradford or ‘bradford’s’ or brighton or ‘brighton’s’ or bristol or ‘bristol’s’ or carlisle* or ‘carlisle’s’ or (cambridge not (massachusetts* or boston* or harvard*)) or (‘cambridge’s’ not (massachusetts* or boston* or harvard*)) or (canterbury not zealand*) or (‘canterbury’s’ not zealand*) or chelmsford or ‘chelmsford’s’ or chester or ‘chester’s’ or chichester or ‘chichester’s’ or coventry or ‘coventry’s’ or derby or ‘derby’s’ or (durham not (carolina* or nc)) or (‘durham’s’ not (carolina* or nc)) or ely or ‘ely’s’ or exeter or ‘exeter’s’ or gloucester or ‘gloucester’s’ or hereford or ‘hereford’s’ or hull or ‘hull’s’ or lancaster or ‘lancaster’s’ or leeds* or leicester or ‘leicester’s’ or (lincoln not nebraska*) or (‘lincoln’s’ not nebraska*) or (liverpool not (new south wales* or nsw)) or (‘liverpool’s’ not (new south wales* or nsw)) or ((london not (ontario* or ont or toronto*)) or (‘london’s’ not (ontario* or ont or toronto*)) or manchester or ‘manchester’s’ or (newcastle not (new south wales* or nsw)) or (‘newcastle’s’ not (new south wales* or nsw)) or norwich or ‘norwich’s’ or nottingham or ‘nottingham’s’ or oxford or ‘oxford’s’ or peterborough or ‘peterborough’s’ or plymouth or ‘plymouth’s’ or portsmouth or ‘portsmouth’s’ or preston or ‘preston’s’ or ripon or ‘ripon’s’ or salford or ‘salford’s’ or salisbury or ‘salisbury’s’ or sheffield or ‘sheffield’s’ or southampton or ‘southampton’s’ or st albans or stoke or ‘stoke’s’ or sunderland or ‘sunderland’s’ or truro or ‘truro’s’ or wakefield or ‘wakefield’s’ or wells or westminster or ‘westminster’s’ or winchester or ‘winchester’s’ or wolverhampton or ‘wolverhampton’s’ or (worcester not (massachusetts* or boston* or harvard*)) or (‘worcester’s’ not (massachusetts* or boston* or harvard*)) or (york not (‘new york*’ or ny or ontario* or ont or toronto*)) or (‘york’s’ not (‘new york*’ or ny or ontario* or ont or toronto*))))).ti,ab,in.
- (bangor or ‘bangor’s’ or cardiff or ‘cardiff’s’ or newport or ‘newport’s’ or st asaph or ‘st asaph’s’ or st davids or swansea or ‘swansea’s’).ti,ab,in.
- (aberdeen or ‘aberdeen’s’ or dundee or ‘dundee’s’ or edinburgh or ‘edinburgh’s’ or glasgow or ‘glasgow’s’ or inverness or (perth not australia*) or (‘perth’s’ not australia*) or stirling or ‘stirling’s’).ti,ab,in.
- (armagh or ‘armagh’s’ or belfast or ‘belfast’s’ or lisburn or ‘lisburn’s’ or londonderry or ‘londonderry’s’ or derry or ‘derry’s’ or newry or ‘newry’s’).ti,ab,in.
- or/44-51
- (exp africa/or exp americas/or exp antarctic regions/or exp arctic regions/or exp asia/or exp australia/or exp oceania/) not (exp United Kingdom/or europe/)
- 52 not 53
- 4 and 32 and 43 and 54 (Nurses)
- 7 and 32 and 43 and 54 (Midwives)
- 24 and 32 and 43 and 54 (Paramedics)
Database: HMIC
Host: Ovid
Issue: 1979 to September 2021
Date searched: 7/12/2021
Searcher: SB
Hits: nurses: 3; midwives: 0; paramedics: 0
Strategy: as per MEDLINE without MeSH (available on request from author)
- Bibliographic database search strategies and results - Causes and solutions to w...Bibliographic database search strategies and results - Causes and solutions to workplace psychological ill-health for nurses, midwives and paramedics: the Care Under Pressure 2 realist review
Your browsing activity is empty.
Activity recording is turned off.
See more...